NEWS · WASHINGTON, D.C.
Former AARO chief says the FBI agents’ black-triangle report lacks the evidence to show what they saw
Sean Kirkpatrick, the Pentagon UFO office’s first director, told Fox News Digital that the witnesses’ jobs don’t make their account evidence. The government’s own two records of the sighting disagree on how long it lasted.

On Sunday, November 1, Fox News Digital published an interview with Sean Kirkpatrick, the first director of the Pentagon’s All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO), about the most talked-about file in the Pentagon’s latest UFO release: a silent black triangle that two federal agents say they watched rise over a ridge. The release, the seventh, came out on October 23, and we covered the records when they appeared. Kirkpatrick, who led AARO until 2023, told Fox that the account lacks the evidence needed to determine what the witnesses actually saw (Fox’s wording, not a direct quote).
What Kirkpatrick said
According to Fox, the files describe a 2026 sighting in which FBI personnel reported a dark triangle, with no engines, exhaust or other means of propulsion that they could see, climbing over a ridge and then disappearing into a canyon. Without photographs or other supporting evidence, Kirkpatrick said, there is no way to tell what, if anything, they saw. He said the witnesses’ backgrounds do not settle the matter, calling the habit of taking credible-seeming witnesses at face value “a classic case of authority bias.”
He also described how people handle a gap in the evidence. “Some of this is just, ‘hey, I saw something, I don’t know what it is,’” he said, adding that people sometimes fill that gap “with very extreme beliefs.” According to Fox, he suggested some triangle reports may reflect secret aerospace technology, likening them to sightings of the F-117 stealth jet before the public knew it existed. He said AARO sorted reports into “3 very distinct buckets”: a foreign adversary’s advanced technology, ordinary objects or sensor effects that people misread, and an extraterrestrial explanation. Fox’s subheadline says he told the outlet that none of the data AARO reviewed matches an extraterrestrial hypothesis.
What the two records say
Kirkpatrick’s point about thin evidence is consistent with what the released documents contain. The sighting appears in two records that disagree. AARO’s memorandum for record, DOW-UAP-D176, describes about ten seconds of vertical climb to 200–300 feet, a hover of about twenty seconds, and then two to three seconds of fast horizontal flight, a bank and a descent into a canyon. The FBI interview form, FBI-UAP-D043, reproduces the agents’ written statement, which says the whole sighting lasted approximately three seconds and says the object most resembled a delta-wing drone. Neither document identifies the object.
AARO does not treat the case as closed or as ordinary. Its description of the memo on the release page says the office considers the incident worth further investigation because the object’s reported shape and movements closely match other reports from the western United States. The memo itself cautions that its descriptions are the witnesses’ interpretations, not proof of any feature or performance, and the agents’ own statement refers to the object as an unmanned aerial system. A thermal monocular showed no exhaust or hot spots, and a search of the canyon the next morning found no wreckage or ground marks, according to the memo. The War Department told Fox that the images released with the FBI report are illustrations, not photographs of the object.
What is and isn’t settled
Kirkpatrick’s comments are the view of one former official, who has long argued that the government’s evidence does not support extraterrestrial claims; his comments are not an AARO finding on this case. Nothing in the release says what the object was, and the files themselves present the sighting as an unresolved witness report, not a confirmed anomaly. What Kirkpatrick’s remarks add is the standard he says AARO applied under his leadership: “actual data, not just a story,” before a conclusion can be drawn. He also told Fox that “unresolved” generally means there is too little data to conclude either way, not that a case is extraterrestrial. The War Department told Fox it is giving no assessment of the files, so that the public can make up its own mind.
Sources
- Fox News: Former Pentagon UFO chief disputes FBI black triangle sighting, says reports lack evidence, November 1, 2026 archived
- Fox News: New Pentagon UFO files detail FBI agents’ sighting of silent triangular object with no visible engines, October 25, 2026 archived
- U.S. Department of War: Pentagon UFO files, Release 7 (DOW-UAP-D176 and FBI-UAP-D043), October 23, 2026 archived


